An OnlyFans creator has pleaded guilty to involuntary manslaughter following the death of a client during a private fetish session that ended in tragedy — a case now raising uncomfortable questions about consent, responsibility, and the risks tied to the monetized underground of online adult content.
Michaela Rylaarsdam, 32, entered the plea nearly two years after Michael Dale, 56, was hospitalized and later declared brain dead following an encounter prosecutors say escalated beyond agreed boundaries. Dale was removed from life support days later, with officials ruling his death the result of asphyxiation.
According to investigators, Dale had paid more than £8,000 for a bondage-themed session in April 2023. Court records state he requested to be wrapped in plastic “like a mummy,” along with additional fetish elements involving adhesive and restricted movement.
When authorities arrived, however, they found Dale unresponsive with plastic wrap covering his body, duct tape placed over his mouth, and a plastic bag positioned over his head — a detail prosecutors emphasized was never requested in the client’s prior communications.
Detective Chris Zack testified that messages recovered from Rylaarsdam’s phone showed the client asking for specific fetish acts, including having his eyes glued shut, but investigators found no evidence he consented to anything obstructing his breathing. Officials later determined the bag had remained over his head for at least eight minutes, leading to fatal oxygen deprivation. The death was formally classified as homicide.
Prosecutors also cited videos and images allegedly recorded during the encounter, some intended for OnlyFans content and others reportedly shared privately after the session began. Emergency services were called roughly four hours after Dale arrived at the property.
Rylaarsdam’s defense argued there was no intent to kill, noting she contacted emergency services herself, attempted lifesaving measures, and cooperated fully with police. Her attorney maintained that the situation became a medical emergency rather than a deliberate act of violence.
She now faces a potential four-year prison sentence, according to reporting from the San Diego Union-Tribune.
Beyond the courtroom, the case underscores a growing reality of the creator economy: as adult content moves from studios into private homes and direct client arrangements, the line between fantasy performance and real-world danger can become dangerously thin.
Hot Chicks Influencers OnlyFans
Last modified: May 15, 2026
